Discussion about this post

User's avatar
uf911's avatar

Resposting a comment I made @ the White Pill

My grandfather and dad were nuclear engineers. My sister and I both grew up destined to be nuclear engineers. I did a couple internships at nuclear power and at LLNL: built dry cask spent fuel storage (Wisconsin), missile shields for spent fuel pool protection (Florida), and radioisotope thermoelectric generators for deep space satellites. Saw how dead the industry was, and went into software full time in 2000. My little sister, though, stuck it out. She has probably built more new nuclear power reactors than any currently practicing engineer in US industry under the age of 75. Not terrestrial power stations, but the reactors designed, built, and maintained at Lockheed ->NNNS->HII that are used in aircraft carriers and submarines.

If the degree of fighting against fully licensing a new terrestrial nuclear plant is the same as it was in the late 1990s, roughly half of the startup costs are from those fights. Lawsuits from environmentalist organizations, lawsuits from local citizens, duplicative insanely expensive site evaluations required by 4-5 layers of overlapping gov't agencies, etc etc.

If there was a regulatory change and automatic protections against environmental and Nimby obstinacy, the small reactors that power carriers and subs could be built all over the country. Small but they have punch, and the knowledge is already available.

Edit for this post:

I just realized there is also another option: bypass state and local jurisdiction, build nukes that operate on the water. The federal government has sole authority over power generation within lakes, and coastal waters. If this sounds ludicrous, consider the numbers: there are currently 93 terrestrial nuclear power reactors running at a total of 54 privately-owned plants, but the US Navy currently operates 83 nuclear-powered submarines and surface ships. Reactors are built on land, but they require direct access to an ocean or a very large lake to vent the excess heat generated by the reactor. High voltage power cabling at scale over water is already done for wind turbine farms in the ocean, the same basics would apply to a nuclear rig in the ocean (but with zero bird kills).

Expand full comment
Dave Goldblatt's avatar

typo:

"For one, vivid imagery from Chernobyl, Fukushima, and Three Mile Island Vivid imagery from events like Chernobyl, and three-mile island, "

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts