Discussion about this post

User's avatar
James Hexter's avatar

After reading the past couple of posts on yours about religion, I'm coming to the conclusion that what atheists/non-theists/etc. want isn't exactly a world without belief systems, per se, but a world with belief systems that a.) are both metaphorically AND literally true, and b.) create useful and long-lasting social cohesion without requiring people in those groups to believe wacky things. I think what attracts some people (like myself) to atheism is because we tend to be extremely literal-minded people who don't prioritize social approval as heavily as others, so we reject religion as nothing but wacky beliefs that inevitably lead to mass graves, genocide, etc. But of course, being an intellectual "lone wolf" of this kind is only possible in a prosperous and developed society as ours, where you don't have to be as reliant on the people around you for your own mere survival. Not to mention that atheists tend to fall into the same trap as everyone else of believing the world would be so much better if everyone believes the same things they do.

None of this is going to stop me from being an atheist, though, or wanting a belief system that meets both criteria above (while realizing that atheism fulfills neither). Just because the current limits of human nature means religion-style beliefs are unavoidable now doesn't mean it must always be thus -- right?

Expand full comment
Mitch P's avatar

Does self-awareness of “wacky beliefs” make belief itself, impossible? If you are aware a set a beliefs are crazy and non-rational is it possible to truly believe them, recognizing the additional value they bring?

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts